Showing posts with label Top Chef. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Top Chef. Show all posts

Sunday, June 8, 2008

"Top Chef" Season 4: Episodes 9 through 13

Let me begin with an explanation: the reason I failed to post any kind of review of the past five episodes is because if I had reviewed them at the time of airing, it would have taken everything in my power not to simply write a string of curses representing the frustration I feel because Lisa has somehow managed to sneak by Judges' Table over these past weeks.

Today's review is no exception to that, and in fact the only way I think I am managing to get through it in a polite and professional manner is the fact that before sitting down to the computer today, I had a lunch which consisted of four cosmopolitans and a Xanax. And quite literally during the ridiculously long pause while I waited to hear Padma say her famous line, I was rocking back and forth on the couch repeating, "Lisa, please pack your knives and go. Lisa, please pack your knives and go," hoping that maybe my chants would somehow enter the TV, deflect off of Tom Colicchio's bald head and straight into Padma's brain.

Since I don't have the time or the the energy, and because I am still recovering from having to say goodbye to Antonia, I have decided to review episodes nine through thirteen in Haiku form. Enjoy:

Episode 9:Wedding Wars
Speed challenge again
At stake, a bride's wedding day
Farewell to Nikki

Episode 10: Serve and Protect
The salmon rolls fail
Unpleasing to tongue and eyes
Like Padma's knife dance.

Episode 11: Restaurant Wars
Team Richard: success
Scary judge, Mr. Bourdain
Butterscotch scallops???

Episode 12: High Steaks
You get it? "High Steaks?"
Like a play on the word "stakes"
So clever, Top Chef

Episode 13: Finale PT 1
Upset at judges
Mad mad mad mad mad mad mad
Lisa can suck it

Tuesday, April 22, 2008

"Top Chef" Season 4: Weeks 4, 5 and 6

Yes, I suck. Moving on.

I think all that needs to be said about week 4 was that I loved, loved, LOVED the film-themed elimination challenge but team Mark and Ryan were robbed! They clearly had the best theme. Come on! A Christmas Story and a meal ode to the giant pack of neighborhood dogs that ruined Christmas dinner, forcing the family to eat Peking Duck, head and all! INGENIOUS!

Week 5. Well this was a sassy little episode was it not? People kicking chairs, Dale grabbing his crotch while yelling at Lisa to further emphasize his problem with her bad attitude -- it was anarchy! Let me give it to you straight: Antonia is my home girl and my number 2 choice to win next to Stephanie but she did have immunity in the elimination challenge and should absolutely have taken a back seat and let Spike and Zoi make whatever dish, soup or otherwise, they wanted. However, she did say she would make the soup if they insisted but strongly cautioned against it. So, go ahead Spike, remove your foot from your perfect pallet and roll back the tape. Regardless, unseasoned food is inexcusable. Goodbye Zoi.

And finally, this week I have to say I was disappointed at the decision at the judges' table. True, the more Ryan spoke about his dish the more annoying he became and no, in no way did a poached pear dessert belong at a tailgate party but at least he took a risk. What risk did Nikki take with a store-bought sausage, pepper and onion hoagie? Not to mention she completely bombed her Quickfire. Fried shrimp and coleslaw? I'm sorry -- is this Top Chef, or is she applying to be a line cook at TGI Friday's? Do I think Ryan was going to make it to the finals? No. But he at least deserved one more shot.

Sunday, March 30, 2008

"Top Chef" Season 4: Week 3

In general, week three was a disappointment for me. It's still early enough in the season where there's just not enough time to see what everyone makes in the "Quickfire" challenges. This week's challenge: to take the humble taco and turn it into a fine dining experience. I love tacos and would gladly eat them every day for lunch, so I was giddy with excitement to see what everyone would come up with. But with 14 contestants remaining and only 60 minutes of show what do they do? They show the top three tacos, the bottom three tacos and the Mexican guy's taco (didn't find that at all offensive).

In this week's elimination challenge, the chefs had to split into two teams and cater a block party for a Chicago neighborhood. But the exciting twist of this challenge was that instead of hopping in their Toyota Highlanders to do their shopping at Whole Foods Market, they had to go shopping door-to-door in said neighborhood. This could only mean one thing: more time for product placements! On the chefs' little scavenger hunt, they came across some pretty amazing finds, such as KC Masterpiece Barbecue Sauce, Hidden Valley "Spicy" Ranch dressing and Velveeta Cheese. Come on, Top Chef! I mean, I understand that you had to jump into bed with the makers of Gladware but Velveeta!?! Orange colored cheese food!?! That is a new low.

I was torn at Judges' Table and I had no idea which of the two teams was the losing team. One thing is for sure: Andrew needs to serve himself a very large slice of humble pie. Um, this is not "your house," you pretentious ass, and whether or not you go home is not your decision to make. Someone needs to lace his olive oil with Ritalin. And I find it even more annoying that he is actually one of the better chefs.

I honestly think I would be way more likely to bring myself to eat Erik's soggy corn dogs over Nikki's coagulated and dry mac-n-cheese (see aforementioned Velveeta). But in the end, Erik was the best choice for going home; his Quickfires have lacked presence and though he seemed like a likable guy, he just couldn't bring the fancy that I love oh so much. But my girl Stephanie prevailed once again with a berry crisp that looked heavenly. Bet it would have been even better with some Kraft brand Cool Whip™.

Sunday, March 23, 2008

"Top Chef" Season 4: Week 2

What a clever little challenge we had this week. The chefs were to cater a party at the Chicago zoo. They were broken up into teams of three and each team was assigned an animal. The challenge was to prepare a menu based on the diet of their assigned animal.

Between the bottom two teams, Team Gorilla and Team Bear, it's difficult for me to decide which of the two was actually the weaker team. On one hand, you have Team Bear, who decided to serve their stuffed mushrooms even though they failed to even taste them before service. (Gail Simmons referred to them as "bear dropping" in appearance. I think Rocco DiSpirito writes her jokes for her).

Then there was Team Gorilla, who I think made a bad move by adding meat to their menu for an animal who has an entirely vegetarian diet. In my opinion, they didn't meet the requirements of the challenge. I mean, what would they have done if a gorilla had come up to their station, eager to eat from a menu designed specifically for him, picked up a plate of Stephanie's seemingly meatless salad only to find out that it was chock-full of crab meat. I can hear it now: "Um excuse me ma'am, is there meat in this?" the gorilla would ask. And after hearing "yes," he would probably ask to speak to the manager, and despite the sincerest of apologies from both the chefs and Ms. Lakshmi, the gorilla would probably still end up throwing his poo at her. How embarrassing for the chefs...and the gorilla.

In the end I think Valerie was a good choice for going home. I know nothing about blinis and when they should or should not be made, but I do think that she was just not tough enough for the title of Top Chef. Plus, she looked just like Rachel Dratch from SNL and I just kept expecting her to get all "Debbie Downer" on us and start talking about the frequency of cross contamination in the kitchen and the number of salmonella deaths per year as a result. Waah-wahhhhhh.

Monday, March 17, 2008

Top Chef Season 4: Week 1

So here is my question: Were Zoi and Jennifer legitimately two of the most qualified chefs in the nation to apply for the show or is Chef Colicchio just hoping that there would be some girl-on-girl action that somehow involved aprons, high heels and truffle oil? Right now, I am doubtful that the first choice is the likelier one.

Furthermore, Andrew, you are not a tough guy just because every other word out of your mouth rhymes with "rubber trucker." You had best keep your attitude in check or you're going to get your ass handed to you, braised in a port and black cherry reduction, served on a bed of field greens.

And I am not sure what was worse, Ryan's shake-n-bake chicken piccata or Rocco DiSpirito's hilarious comment about him and his dish: "Let's just say that the gnocchi was not the only thing that was dense!" I mean come one! With more zingers like that one, this is "cooking up" to be a "tasty" season. (See how I did that there?)

To sum up, I believe that Nimma was the best choice for going home. Over-salting a meal is an inexcusable offense, and calling her failed flan a "cauliflower scramble" does not make it look any less like barf on a plate.

My current favorite to win: Stephanie. More than the fact that she was able to impress Anthony Bourdain with her Duck a L'Orange, but because she seems sincere, not to mention very talented in an entirely unpretentious way. Those are the kind of people I root for.

You can read more about the "Top Chef" Season 4...um..."Cheftestants" here.